ATAR Examination- Comprehending- Modelled Response to Image

 

 

The image above is taken from the 2016 ATAR English examination and can be found at the following website:

https://comicstore.marvel.com/Once-Upon-A-Time-Shadow-Of-The-Queen/digital-comic/31546

The question from the 2016 ATAR English examination relating to this question was:

Explain the visual element that has the greatest effect on your interpretation of this image.

 

The response above is taken from the Good Answers Guide ATAR English 2017 (published by the ETAWA) and has also been annotated on the right-hand side. It is worth reading as a model example and your attention is drawn to:

  • The length of the response- It is 249 words long and this is considered an ideal length.
  • The response is focused entirely on body language as the most influential visual feature.
  • It is an assertive and self-confident interpretation of the text.
  • There is clear control of language and there is a distinctive voice.
  • Opening sentence offers a clear proposition in response to the question without simply restating it.
  • Second sentence offers a clear interpretation of the image.
  • Language choices offer a distinctive voice and is convincing.
  • Every additional sentence builds on the central idea and refers to a further aspect of how body language is used.
  • Short sentences make the point clearly and succinctly.
  • Conclusion is largely unnecessary and there is no requirement to write one in the Comprehending section.

When the assessment criteria (above) is applied to a reading of this model answer, it’s clear that it meets the criteria for a highly successful response.

You will need to use the modelled example (above) to construct your own responses to the images of disability we explored in our previous lesson.

 

SCSA’s perspective on the criteria for a successful response in the Comprehending section:

  • Concise and succinct
  • Students might benefit from the advice below:
    • Think More
    • Write Less
    • Work Better
  • The most successful responses demonstrated control of generic conventions.
  • Short answers are not required to be written in an essay-style structure.
  • Students are advised to not ‘regurgitate’ content, particularly considering that they have a limited time in which to respond. Some of the most effective responses were considerably shorter than the advised word limit because they were concise and succinct.
  • First sentence should be a thesis statement.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *